Chapter 2.1 — Animals
The poet says he could change his way of life and live among animals instead, because animals are calm and self-composed. He could stand and watch them for hours together.
He has observed that animals do not feel anxious or troubled, and they do not keep trying to improve their condition. They never complain mournfully about how they live. They do not lie awake at night regretting their sins. They do not disturb the poet by endlessly discussing their duty to God. Not a single animal seems dissatisfied. None of them behaves foolishly or madly chases after owning possessions. No animal kneels before another in worship, nor do they worship any ancestor that lived centuries ago.
Animals are neither overjoyed nor unhappy about the state of the whole world. They express their bond with the poet in a simple way, and he, in turn, accepts them just as they are.
Animals show the poet clear signs of qualities such as innocence and simplicity, and their behaviour reveals how naturally these qualities belong to them.
The poet wonders where the animals got these tokens from.
He also wonders whether mankind (represented by the poet himself) once possessed these same qualities long ago, and then, over time, carelessly gave them up.
The poem ‘Animals’ is written by the poet Walt Whitman. It is written in free verse and does not follow any fixed rhyme scheme. My favourite line in the poem is “They do not lie awake in the dark and weep for their sins,” as it is deeply meaningful and carries a strong moral message. The central idea of the poem is about how we should live our lives: the poet wishes he could be an animal, because animals live without tension or worry, do not work hard to acquire possessions, and do not cry over their condition. The poem uses figures of speech such as Alliteration, Repetition, Hyperbole, Metaphor, and Personification to make it more effective. It is highly effective overall, and its tone is optimistic about life, while its language remains simple yet meaningful. Since animals do not commit sins, they do not lie awake at night in fear of them, nor do they discuss their duty to God; instead, they are content with what they have and do not chase after possessions madly, and they do not bow before one another, treating each other as equals, with none superior to another. I like this poem very much, and I find the poet’s thoughts inspiring, as he shows us how we should live — like animals, treating everyone equally and with respect — and tells us that we should not regret or feel upset about what we have, but should live happily and with optimism.
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| turn | (here) transform |
| placid | not easily upset |
| self-contain’d | self-sufficient |
| mania | craze |
| demented | mad |
| respectable | (here) too happy and satisfied |
| evince | show |
| tokens | (here) virtues like innocence, simplicity, contentment, etc. |
| make me sick | disgust me |
Discuss with your partner what Mark Twain means by this quote. Write it in your own words.
Human
- cooks
- learns computing
- stands up immediately (as infants, with help)
- worships God
- good manners
Common to Both
- self-control
- communicates
- love and care
- shows gratitude
- swims
- brings up children
Animals
- can live for more than 150 years
- sleeps in a standing position
- has 360° vision
- belongs to various species after birth
| Amphibians | Mammals | Wild Animals | Aquatic Animals | Pet Animals |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| frog | cow | lion | octopus | cat |
| toad | bat | tiger | crocodile | dog |
| salamander | squirrel | bear | alligator | guinea pig |
| caecilian | mongoose | wolf | hippopotamus | goldfish |
| cheetah | turtle | |||
| leopard | ||||
| monkey |
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| whine | complain in an annoying way |
| sin | an offence against religious or moral law |
| evince | show |
| mania | craze |
| negligent | failing to take proper care |
| Positive | Negative |
|---|---|
| placid | dissatisfied |
| self-contain’d | demented |
| unhappy | |
| negligent |
| Human Beings | Animals |
|---|---|
| Always complain about their condition. | Never complain about anything. |
| Spend sleepless nights regretting their sins. | Do not regret their sins at all. |
| Sicken others by discussing their duty to God. | Do not discuss their duty to God. |
| Are always dissatisfied. | Are always contented. |
| Are crazy about acquiring possessions. | Are never interested in owning things. |
| Worship other human beings. | Never worship any of their own kind. |
| Are always unhappy about earthly matters. | Remain unconcerned about earthly matters. |
Good Values & Habits Learnt from Animals
- They are placid and self-contained.
- They do not idle away their time discussing their duty to God.
- They are not crazy about owning things, and are happy with the resources they have.
- They do not worship other humans or any ancestors.
- They show qualities of innocence and simplicity.
- They do not criticize what they already have, or complain about their condition.
| Figure of Speech | Lines |
|---|---|
| Repetition | “I stand and look at them long and long.” / “They do not sweat and whine…” / “They do not lie awake…” / “They do not make…” / “Not one is dissatisfied, not one is demented…” |
| Alliteration | “Not one is dissatisfied, not one is demented…” / “…they evince them plainly in their possession.” |
| Hyperbole | “Not one is respectable or unhappy over the whole earth.” |
| View | Counterview |
|---|---|
| Animals are placid and self-contained. | Animals cannot improve their condition in life. |
| Animals do not try to set targets or achieve goals, unlike humans. | By setting targets, humans are able to achieve their goals. |
| Animals do not complain about their condition. | It is only by complaining that one comes to know how things can be improved. |
| Animals are self-satisfied with their condition, whatever it may be. | Humans continuously try to improve their living conditions. |
| Animals do not worship other things, animals, or persons as gods. | Animals have no idea of God, while humans acknowledge a divine Creator. |
| Animals do not worry about possessions or earthly matters. | Animals do not care about the future of this planet, while humans do. |
View: Unlike humans, animals are placid and self-contained. They do not try to set targets or achieve goals as humans do. They do not complain about their condition, and remain satisfied with their living conditions, whatever they may be. Moreover, they do not worship things, other animals, or people as gods, nor are they overly concerned about possessions or earthly matters.
Counter-view: Since animals are self-contained and self-satisfied, they feel no need to improve their living conditions. Humans, being restless, complain about their lives — and as a result, continuously strive to improve their conditions. By setting targets, humans are able to achieve their goals. While animals have no idea of God, humans acknowledge a divine Creator. Because animals do not worry about possessions or earthly matters, they also do not possess the will to care about the future of the planet, as humans do.
